Education & Career Trends: July 31, 2024
Curated by the Knowledge Team of ICS Career GPS
- Article by Saumya Malviya, published on thewire.in
In the realm of mathematics education, there is a growing recognition of the benefits that come from incorporating the philosophy and history of the subject. This approach enriches students’ understanding and appreciation of mathematics in several significant ways.
Consider the journey of the author, who began with an undergraduate degree in mathematics, followed by advanced training in sociology, culminating in a PhD thesis on the sociology of mathematical practices. This background offers a unique perspective on why integrating philosophical and historical discourses into mathematics education is beneficial.
Philosophical Insights into Mathematical Practices
Engaging with thinkers like Gottlob Frege, Ludwig Wittgenstein and Ernst Cassirer allows students to see mathematical symbols and conventions in a new light. Symbols such as ∃, ∀, and ¬ are not just abstract notations but carry commitments to universality, generality or uniqueness. This perspective reveals the subtleties in mathematical formulas, making them more than just representational schemas.
Historical Context and Mathematical Formalism
Philosophical and historical works on mathematics, including those by Kurt Gödel and Emmy Noether, open up new ways of understanding mathematical formalism. The signs used in mathematics are similar to practices like calligraphy and woodcarving, highlighting the craft-like nature of mathematics. This understanding helps students appreciate the evolution and context of mathematical practices.
Developing Critical and Reflexive Thinking
Engaging with the philosophy and history of mathematics helps students develop a critical and reflexive relationship with their practice. This is not about providing a ready-made framework but about inducing reflections suggested by the practice itself. It encourages students to see mathematics not just as a set of skills but as a branch of critical thought.
Understanding Intuition and Social Context
Exploring the relationship between mathematics and intuition can show how the intuitive and the social are intertwined. For example, understanding the Zermelo-Fraenkel axioms in light of set theory paradoxes changes how these axioms are received and understood, highlighting their materialistic nature and the stakes involved in mathematical discourse.
Enriching Classroom Exchanges
Familiarity with the philosophical discourse on mathematics can lead to more informed and sensitive classroom exchanges. It allows students to see mathematical problems as dynamic and evolving, rather than static and purely technical. This perspective fosters a deeper engagement with the subject.
Learning from the History of Mathematics
Reading histories of mathematics, such as Senthil Babu’s “Mathematics and Society,” helps students see how mathematical practices are embedded in cultural and social contexts. This understanding can lead to questions about how modern university mathematics is shaped by different institutional cultures and the broader politics of knowledge.
Addressing Potential Objections
Some might argue that studying the philosophy and history of mathematics is a distraction for budding mathematicians. However, this view stems from an instrumentalist understanding of mathematics, where the subject is seen purely as a set of skills to be mastered. In reality, integrating these discourses enriches the ways of doing mathematics, generating critical and creative reflections on the subject.
Conclusion
The National Education Policy (NEP) in India emphasizes an interdisciplinary approach, which aligns with the perspective of integrating the philosophy and history of mathematics into education. However, there is a need to ensure that this approach does not lead to a superficial understanding of mathematics. Instead, it should foster an appreciation of mathematics as a form of critical thought, similar to art or music.
Ultimately, integrating the philosophy and history of mathematics into education requires thoughtful implementation by educators and stakeholders. This approach can make mathematics more inclusive and representational, enriching students’ learning experiences and fostering a deeper love and understanding of the subject.
…
Have you checked out yesterday’s blog yet
10 Career Paths in Business Analytics
(Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the article mentioned above are those of the author(s). They do not purport to reflect the opinions or views of ICS Career GPS or its staff.)
Like this post? For more such helpful articles, click on the button below and subscribe FREE to our blog.
Download our mobile app, ICS Career GPS, a one-stop career guidance platform.
One Reply to “Why Mathematics Students Need to Be Taught the Philosophy and History of the Subject”